Thoughts from after Maine
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
I think we did a lot of good in Maine. I really do. But I'm left wondering how long it will take to change enough hearts and minds that we win one of these ballot initiatives? I talked to dozens and dozens of voters over GOTV weekend and the Yes on 1 folks are not bad people. They really believe that it's not about gay rights. Many of them are for making civil unions/domestic partnerships equal to marriage--even at the federal level. And they really believe that they are called by their god to protect traditional marriage. They aren't trying to be bigoted.

But they are.

And that's the bottom line. In order for you to feel comfortable making distinctions between classes of people, you must first assume that these groups are different--in a legal sense.

For example, anyone would agree that a mother, father and child recently immigrated from Honduras is somewhat different than a family of hundreds in Massachusetts who all descend from people who came over on the Mayflower. They have been here for different lengths of time. They may speak different languages and may have different cultural behaviors. They probably look different.

But are they different under the law? Should we afford certain rights to the immigrants, but withhold other rights from the Mayflower descendants?

Of course, there is some difference between a same-sex marriage and a different-sex marriage. But should those differences matter under the law?

Supporters of Marriage Equality generally believe that those differences don't really matter at all. Certainly not under the law.

Unfortunately, we couldn't get enough people in Maine to see it that way. Someday we will wonder what all the fuss was about.

Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

No comments have been written yet.

Community Posts

1St Grade Reading
Posted Dec 01, 2011 8:44pm
by Unknown user
Comments (0)

Salon Computer Software
Posted Nov 22, 2011 8:59pm
by Unknown user
Comments (0)

Business_Link
Posted Nov 17, 2011 4:24am
by Unknown user
Comments (0)

Read More >

Recent Comments

Re: Voting Guide for Judicial?
Frustrating that the Courage Campaign did not prov...

Re: Voting Guide for Judicial?
Frustrating that the Courage Campaign did not prov...

Re: Voting Guide for Judicial?
Unfortunately there is almost no discussion about ...

Voting Guide for Judicial?
Can't seem to find any guide for judicial? Can you...

Proposition 8 is about Equality!
Proposition 8 is all about equality! The Founding ...


Blog Roll


Calitics
The Bayne of Blog
California Progress Report
California Majority Report
D-Day
DailyKos Down With Tyranny
Fog City Journal
High Speed Rail Blog
Left in SF
The Liberal OC
Living in the O
Michigan Liberal
MyDD
OB Rag
San Diego Politico
Square State
Surf Putah
Sweet Melissa
Unite the Fight